Submission decision
Revise before submission
The selected journal remains credible, but methods reporting should be clarified before the manuscript enters editorial review.
This example is illustrative. A real review is based on the selected journal, article type, and the manuscript you provide.
Submission decision
The selected journal remains credible, but methods reporting should be clarified before the manuscript enters editorial review.
Priority finding
Eligibility criteria and the analytic approach are present but not yet explicit enough for a reader to follow without interpretation.
Why it matters
When the cohort logic and statistical framework are hard to reconstruct, an editor or reviewer may pause before considering the manuscript's central result.
Revision path
State the eligibility criteria, prespecified outcome, and core statistical method where a reader expects to find them. Then recheck the target journal's submission requirements.
Ready to see your manuscript in context?
Start a manuscript review